Thumb CMC arthritis surgery: LRTI reconstruction and joint replacement
thumb arthritis surgery CMC joint replacement, thumb joint replacement, thumb base arthroplasty, LRTI surgery, trapeziectomy, CMC arthroplasty, basal joint arthritis surgery LRTI vs CMC joint replacem...
Surgery for thumb CMC joint arthritis relieves pain and restores grip when splints, exercises and injections no longer help. The two main operations are reconstruction surgery (LRTI) and CMC joint replacement. This page explains how surgery is planned, how each operation works, how they compare and what recovery looks like. For symptoms and causes, see our article on CMC joint arthritis of the thumb.
Investigations
Most people need only a hand examination and an X-ray to confirm thumb arthritis and plan treatment. Other tests are used only when the diagnosis is unclear.
Clinical examination
Your doctor examines your hand and checks:
- Exactly where you feel pain
- Tenderness when the base of the thumb is pressed
- The shape of the thumb base, looking for swelling, a bony bump or a joint that has shifted
- Pain when the base of the thumb is gently pressed and rotated (grind test)
- Pinch and grip strength, and how well the thumb moves
- Signs of related hand conditions, such as carpal tunnel syndrome, which often occur alongside thumb arthritis
X-ray
An X-ray shows how far the arthritis has progressed in the thumb's first CMC joint. It can reveal narrowing of the joint space, bone spurs, cysts and changes in joint alignment. It also shows whether the neighbouring joints in the wrist are affected, which matters when choosing between surgical options.
Doctors often grade the X-ray findings into stages:
|
Stage |
What the X-ray shows |
|---|---|
|
Stage 1 |
Joint outline normal or slightly widened |
|
Stage 2 |
Mild joint space narrowing, small bone spurs |
|
Stage 3 |
Marked joint space narrowing, larger bone spurs |
|
Stage 4 |
Arthritis also involves the nearby scaphotrapeziotrapezoid (STT) joint in the wrist |
Other tests
These are not needed for most people:
- Blood tests, if rheumatoid arthritis or another inflammatory arthritis is suspected
- Ultrasound or MRI, if the cause of pain is unclear or a tendon or ligament problem is suspected
- Nerve conduction studies, if you also have numbness or tingling that suggests carpal tunnel syndrome
Treatment
Treatment for thumb arthritis usually follows a step-by-step approach. Most people start with simple, nonsurgical care. If symptoms don't improve, the next step is an injection, and surgery is considered when other treatments no longer help.
Nonsurgical treatment
- Warm-water exercises. Gentle thumb and hand exercises done in warm water for 4 to 6 weeks can ease pain and improve how well the hand and thumb work.
- Splinting. A thumb spica splint supports the joint and limits movement so it can rest. It's usually worn at night and during periods of rest.
- Steroid injection. If exercises don't bring enough relief, a small dose of corticosteroid injected into the thumb base joint can reduce pain and swelling. Relief typically lasts 4 to 6 months.
Surgery
Surgery is recommended for advanced CMC joint arthritis, or when nonsurgical treatments haven't helped. There are two main operations: reconstruction surgery (LRTI) and CMC joint replacement. Both relieve pain well, and your surgeon will advise which suits your X-ray findings, bone quality and activity needs.
Reconstruction surgery (LRTI)
This operation removes the worn joint and uses a tendon to rebuild support. It's called trapeziectomy with ligament reconstruction and tendon interposition (LRTI), and it has a long track record of reliable pain relief.
During the procedure, your surgeon:
- Makes three incisions: one about 4 cm long at the side of the thumb base, and two small 1 cm cuts, one at the wrist and one at the middle of the forearm.
- Removes the trapezium, the small wrist bone at the base of the thumb.
- Releases half of the flexor carpi radialis (FCR) tendon in the forearm and brings it down to the base of the thumb.
- Drills a small tunnel through the base of the thumb's metacarpal bone.
- Passes the tendon through the tunnel and back into the joint space to rebuild the ligament.
- Rolls up the rest of the tendon and places it in the gap, where it works as a cushion (spacer) between the bones.
- Repairs the ligaments at the side of the joint, then closes the soft tissues and skin.
CMC joint replacement surgery
CMC joint replacement (thumb base arthroplasty) replaces the worn joint surfaces with a small artificial ball-and-socket joint, similar in principle to a hip replacement. Unlike reconstruction, the trapezium bone is kept, which helps preserve thumb length and strength.
Who is suitable. Joint replacement suits people whose arthritis is limited to the thumb's CMC joint. The trapezium must be large and strong enough to hold the implant, and the nearby STT joint in the wrist should be free of arthritis. Your surgeon decides this from your examination and X-ray.
During the procedure, your surgeon:
- Makes a single incision over the base of the thumb.
- Opens the joint and removes the worn joint surfaces and bone spurs.
- Fixes a small cup into the trapezium.
- Fixes a stem into the thumb's metacarpal bone, topped with a neck and ball.
- Fits the ball into the cup, then checks the thumb's movement and stability.
- Repairs the joint capsule and closes the skin.
The operation is usually done as a day case. Many modern implants use a dual-mobility design, which aims to make the new joint more stable and less likely to dislocate.
Benefits of joint replacement include:
- Faster early recovery and return to daily tasks
- Quicker return of pinch and grip strength
- Thumb length and a more natural thumb movement are preserved
- If the implant ever fails, it can usually be converted to a trapeziectomy with good results
Risks of joint replacement include:
- Dislocation of the new joint, reported in about 3% to 4% of cases
- Loosening or wear of the implant over time, which may need revision surgery
- A break in nearby bone during surgery
- Infection, nerve irritation, stiffness and scar tenderness, as with any hand surgery
Modern thumb implants show good survival, with around 9 in 10 still working at 5 to 10 years. Long-term results are not yet as well proven as for hip and knee replacements.
Reconstruction or joint replacement?
Both operations relieve pain well. Studies suggest joint replacement gives a faster early recovery, while reconstruction has the longer track record and fewer implant-related risks.
|
|
Reconstruction (LRTI) |
Joint replacement |
|---|---|---|
|
Trapezium bone |
Removed |
Kept |
|
Incisions |
Three: thumb base, wrist and forearm |
One, at the thumb base |
|
Splint after surgery |
About 4 weeks |
Usually 2 to 4 weeks |
|
Pinch strength back to pre-surgery level (studies) |
About 6 months |
About 6 weeks |
|
Return to full activities |
About 3 months |
Daily tasks within weeks; heavy loading limited for about 3 months |
|
Main specific risks |
Temporary weakness, slower recovery |
Dislocation, loosening, revision surgery |
|
Track record |
Decades of reliable results |
Newer; long-term results still being studied |
|
Suitable when |
Arthritis at any stage, including the STT joint |
Arthritis limited to the CMC joint, with good trapezium bone |
Recovery and rehabilitation
Recovery after either operation is guided by a physiotherapist through structured rehabilitation. Most people return to full activities about 3 months after surgery, with joint replacement usually allowing earlier use of the hand.
After reconstruction surgery (LRTI)
- Weeks 0 to 4. You'll wear a thumb splint for about 4 weeks. Gentle passive movements of the thumb begin early, with help from a physiotherapist, to prevent stiffness.
- By week 6. Full thumb movement is expected by about 6 weeks.
- Strengthening. Exercises then build up the muscles that control the thumb, using both concentric (muscle-shortening) and eccentric (muscle-lengthening) movements.
- By 3 months. Most people can return to full activities, including work and hobbies.
After joint replacement
- Weeks 0 to 4. A splint or cast is usually worn for 2 to 4 weeks. Gentle movement of the thumb starts early under a physiotherapist's guidance.
- Weeks 4 to 12. Light daily tasks resume within weeks. Grip-heavy activities usually return around 8 to 12 weeks.
- First 3 months. Very heavy loading of the thumb is avoided while the bone grows firmly into the implant, which lowers the risk of loosening.
- By 3 months. Most people have full, normal use of the thumb.
Frequently asked questions
What tests are used to diagnose thumb arthritis?
A hand examination and an X-ray are usually enough. The X-ray shows how advanced the arthritis is and helps your doctor plan treatment.
Do I need an MRI for thumb arthritis?
Usually not. Ultrasound or MRI is used only if the cause of pain is unclear or another problem, such as a tendon or ligament injury, is suspected.
Can thumb arthritis be treated without surgery?
Yes. Many people improve with warm-water exercises, a thumb spica splint and, if needed, a steroid injection. Surgery is usually considered only when these treatments don't give enough relief.
How long does a steroid injection for thumb arthritis last?
A small dose of steroid injected into the thumb base joint typically relieves pain for about 4 to 6 months.
Does wearing a thumb splint help?
A thumb spica splint rests the joint and can ease pain. It's most helpful when worn at night and during periods of rest.
When is surgery needed for thumb arthritis?
Surgery is recommended for advanced CMC joint arthritis, or when exercises, splinting and injections haven't helped enough.
What is the difference between LRTI surgery and CMC joint replacement?
LRTI surgery removes the trapezium bone and uses part of a forearm tendon to rebuild the ligament and cushion the joint. Joint replacement keeps the trapezium and replaces the worn surfaces with a small ball-and-socket implant. Replacement usually gives a faster early recovery, while LRTI has the longer track record.
Who is a good candidate for CMC joint replacement?
People whose arthritis is limited to the thumb's CMC joint, with a trapezium bone large and strong enough to hold the implant. It's not suitable if the nearby STT joint in the wrist is also arthritic.
How long does a thumb joint replacement last?
With modern implants, around 9 in 10 are still working 5 to 10 years after surgery. If an implant fails, it can usually be converted to a trapeziectomy.
How long is recovery after thumb arthritis surgery?
After LRTI, you'll wear a splint for about 4 weeks, regain full thumb movement by about 6 weeks and return to full activities by about 3 months. After joint replacement, the splint is usually needed for 2 to 4 weeks, and daily tasks often resume sooner.
Will I need physiotherapy after surgery?
Yes. A physiotherapist starts gentle movements early and later guides strengthening exercises for the muscles that control the thumb.
Schedule a Consultation
Would you like to learn more about this procedure or schedule a consultation with our specialists?
Related Procedures
Trigger Finger Treatment
trigger finger trigger finger treatment, trigger finger surgery, trigger finger release, trigger fi...
Thumb ulnar collateral ligament (UCL) Surgery (gamekeeper's thumb)
thumb UCL tear gamekeeper's thumb, skier's thumb, ulnar collateral ligament injury thumb, Stener les...
Carpal Tunnel Syndrome Treatment
carpal tunnel syndrome treatment carpal tunnel surgery, carpal tunnel release, nerve conduction stud...